Disclaimer: I have not finished reading chapter 25 yet...
Today during class, I started reading chapter 25 of Invisible Man and I came across a quote that stuck out to me: "I felt no need to lead or leave them; was glad to follow" (Ellison 542). When I read it, I felt a sort of excitement for the narrator. He is at a crossroads in the scene when he thinks this -- he is able to either stay with the men, Dupre and Scofield, and keep looting the surrounding stores, or he can continue on with his original intentions of helping to calm the chaos that is going on in Harlem. I was proud of the narrator when he chose to "follow" Dupre and Scofield because it was his decision to do so. Up until this point, the narrator has struggled a lot with being forced to do things and having his freedom repressed. In the case of the Brotherhood, the narrator was forced into things from the start. He did not want to take the job with them, but the weight of his economic instability and Jack's persistence led him to call them back. Once he was in the Brotherhood, he was not given much say in what he did or what happened to him. If they wanted him at a party, he was told to go rather than asked if he wanted to or not. When giving a speech, the narrator was forced to stick within a set of guidelines predetermined by the Brotherhood, despite his natural inclination to draw from his emotional connection to the people. Before the Brotherhood, the narrator was constantly being ordered around at the paint factory by Brockway and Kimbro, and the only reason he ended up at the paint factory is because he was ordered to go to New York by Bledsoe. This scene was different from the rest of the book because the narrator was given the option of continuing down the path with the Brotherhood, one where he would be constantly ordered around while being under the illusion that he is a leader with power, or joining this new group of Harlem looters, where he would be fully aware that he was subjecting himself to being a follower. Neither option is good necessarily, but at least he is exercising agency with the second option. Basically, I felt proud of the narrator at this point because he is finally making decisions for himself. Sorry if this post is kind of incoherent, and if you disagree, I would love to here your opinions.
Tuesday, September 30, 2014
Thursday, September 18, 2014
The Narrator is a Blonde Prostitute
We talked the other day in class about the similar dream-like quality in the battle royal scene and the scene in the hospital. In the battle royal scene, the narrator fights in a "big mirrored hall" that is "foggy with cigar smoke," (18). The battle is literally smoke and mirrors, but it is also an illusion that the fighting will benefit these black men, when in reality it is harmful to their health and dignities. The room has an overpowering smell of tobacco and whiskey, implying that the audience present are under the influence and therefore have fewer inhibitions. They are going to act differently than how they would in everyday reality. There are also a lot of examples of the narrator feeling that he has no power over his actions, a feeling commonly experienced in dreams. He says, "But as we tried to leave we were stopped and ordered to get into the ring. There was nothing to do but what we were told," (21). There is "sensual" clarinet music in the background, many shouting voices and noises that blend together, and people invading his personal space from all angles. Eventually he is thrust into darkness by a blindfold, saying on page 22, "Blindfolded, I could no longer control my motions." This further proves the lack of control similar to a dream. He can't even take full responsability for getting himself into the situation. He could have avoided the battle royal had he known better and he could have chosen not to pull the white valve, but again, he didn't know any better; he had very little control over his hospitalization. Once he is in the hospital, he experiences the surreality of a dream. He is awake and alert when the doctors discuss how to treat him, he tries to speak out to them, but they can't hear him. This is a typical scenario for a dream -- not being able to be heard by anybody -- and adds to the confusion and frustration of the chapter. Continuing with the smoke and mirrors idea, the scene in the hospital is an illusion of sorts. Hospitals are supposed to be places that help one get better, to fix what is broken. However, and this might just be my opinion, the "fixing" that the doctors want to do isn't helpful and shows the selfishness of these doctors. They want to try the lobotomy-like procedure, even though they are unsure of the reprecussions it may have on the narrator, and they yell, "Hush goddamit [...] shut up!" at him when he complains about pain and discomfort (232). The "fixing" that goes on in this scene only leaves the narrator frustrated and confused about his identity. The narrator is thrown into this operation without his permission and must go along with it. His situation reminded me of the naked lady dancing in the battle royal scene. She gets picked up by the powerful, drunk white men and thrown about. They disregard her needs and comfort and all the while, she is "fixed-smiling" because she can't speak out about her desires (20). The narrator's doctors are drunk on the desire to try something new for their own personal gain and he has no control over it either. I guess you could say that the narrator is a blonde prostitute.
Thursday, September 11, 2014
Incoherent Thoughts on Deregotory Words
Back when Mr. Mitchell asked us to consider our personal histories with the n-word, we talked about how there are also a number of derogatory terms for people of other races, but none hold as much negative connotation and hatred as this one does. I was reminded of this discussion the other night when I was reading chapter 10 of Invisible Man and the narrator gets angry with Mr. Kimbro. He refers to Kimbro as "a northern redneck, a Yankee cracker," (200-201). While the terms "redneck" and "cracker" are both meant to be used in an offensive way, the only reason their usage stood out to me was because I had that discussion in mind. On the other hand, when Dr. Bledsoe uses the n-word when addressing the narrator, both the narrator and I were taken aback. Part of the reason Bledsoe using it was so surprising to me was because a black man used it in an aggressive way to another black man. In my experience, the n-word has either been used by white people to degrade black people or by black people to address other black people in a brotherly and friendly manner. My experience with the word " cracker" has been very different. My brother used it to address me a couple of times when I was younger, but my parents got mad and told him to stop. I knew that it was an offensive word, but it also wasn't complete taboo. The point that I'm trying to make here is that there are a number of offensive words used to refer to white people, but none of them are nearly as bad as the n-word, or at least none that I can think of. I'm not suggesting that we make it a daily habit to use this word, but I also think that by avoiding saying it, we give power to the word. This is a really rambling post and I apologize because I'm not sure where I'm going/how to wrap it up but...the end.
Thursday, September 4, 2014
Ignorance
Jim Trueblood's story is not a pleasant one, nor does it inspire much sympathy in me as a reader, but the white people who hear it feel the need to help him out. Rich white men, such as Mr. Norton, give him money for toys, clothes, food, etc., almost as if they are paying him off for raping his daughter. I think that the reason they are rewarding Trueblood is not because he committed a terrible act, but rather because he committed a terrible act that confirmed their expectations of him. The stereotype of a poor, black man is that he behaves in an unrespectable way, such as raping his daughter. The white men are content with this stereotypical man, as long as his actions are contained within the black community. The reason that chaos follows Mary's death in Native Son is because these stereotypical actions spilled over into white affairs. They didn't care about Bessie's murder, because that was a disaster that only affected black people. The narrator in Invisible Man is enraged when Trueblood tells his story to Mr. Norton because he knows that, just like all the other white men who have listened to the story, Norton will make a generalization about the black race as a whole based solely on Trueblood's actions. However, as we learned in philosophy class, an example cannot be a definition, so the white men who use Trueblood as a definition of black men don't actually know what they're talking about. The narrator is aware of this and shows the reader, but Norton and other white men remain ignorant, much to my dismay.
Monday, September 1, 2014
The Dalton Family
Native Son was a hard book for me to read because I felt very unsympathetic towards the main character. Bigger bullied his family and friends and contained a lot of anger. While it is understandable why he would be angry at his situation in life, it was still not fun to read. When he went to work for the Daltons, I was excited for Bigger. I thought, "Here is a nice family that will pay him, give him food and shelter, and, hopefully, keep him from robbing stores or making other bad decisions." Mr. Dalton pays him a good amount of money, including a $5 bonus, and tells Bigger that if there are any concerns, he will listen to them. Bigger thinks, "This would be an easy life. Everything was all right, except that girl. ... Maybe he would just have to get used to her; that was all," (59). I saw Bigger working at the Daltons a way to turn his life around and I was hopeful, until he killed Mary. The main reason I got upset with him for killing her was because I felt that he had ruined his chances at a good life working for the Daltons. They were good people who were just trying to help him and he killed their daughter. However, as I progressed through the plot, I became less sympathetic towards the Daltons and more so towards Bigger. Mr. Dalton thought that he was doing such a good thing by taking in this poor, black boy and giving him a job and other benefits. He thought that donating 12 ping-pong tables to the South Side Boys' Club made him a saint. He had donated 5 million dollars "to colored people" so he must be a good guy. Even though Mr. Dalton tried to help, he didn't accomplish anything. If he wanted to help, he could lower the renting rates of his apartments in the Black Belt, but even when Bigger tells him how much his family pays for a low-quality, one-room apartment, Mr. Dalton remains oblivious. He is removed from the situation and therefore cannot actually help, but he not only tries to act as though he is doing a good deed, he also does not admit to the fact that he exercises agency in Mary's murder case. He has the money and power to actually make a difference in the inequality between whites and blacks, but instead he presents himself as being superior to Bigger, especially when he emphasizes that he only needs to pay Bigger $20 per week but he is giving him an extra $5. Mr. Dalton's behavior perpetuates Bigger's hatred towards whites that leads him to be proud of the fact that he killed Mary. Mary also perpetuates this hatred by disrespecting Bigger and asking to see into his world. She is under the impression that she is helping Bigger by appearing to be his equal, but she does the opposite. She claims she wants to "see how [Bigger's] people live," but seeing is not the same as understanding and feeling. It is on the surface, just like Mary's desire to help blacks and whites be equal (69). She says blacks are human, too, but she refers to whites as "us" and blacks as "them" and therefore further separates the two races. Mary makes Bigger feel uncomfortable, and then angry for feeling uncomfortable, and the hatred grows even stronger. It became hard for me to sympathize with the Daltons as I began to understand where Bigger's hatred and emotions were coming from and I developed a sort of hatred for the Daltons, too. They're manipulative and selfish, but also ignorant, and ignorance is hard to cure. However, even when I try to forgive their ignorance, I cannot forgive their actions.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)