Monday, September 1, 2014
The Dalton Family
Native Son was a hard book for me to read because I felt very unsympathetic towards the main character. Bigger bullied his family and friends and contained a lot of anger. While it is understandable why he would be angry at his situation in life, it was still not fun to read. When he went to work for the Daltons, I was excited for Bigger. I thought, "Here is a nice family that will pay him, give him food and shelter, and, hopefully, keep him from robbing stores or making other bad decisions." Mr. Dalton pays him a good amount of money, including a $5 bonus, and tells Bigger that if there are any concerns, he will listen to them. Bigger thinks, "This would be an easy life. Everything was all right, except that girl. ... Maybe he would just have to get used to her; that was all," (59). I saw Bigger working at the Daltons a way to turn his life around and I was hopeful, until he killed Mary. The main reason I got upset with him for killing her was because I felt that he had ruined his chances at a good life working for the Daltons. They were good people who were just trying to help him and he killed their daughter. However, as I progressed through the plot, I became less sympathetic towards the Daltons and more so towards Bigger. Mr. Dalton thought that he was doing such a good thing by taking in this poor, black boy and giving him a job and other benefits. He thought that donating 12 ping-pong tables to the South Side Boys' Club made him a saint. He had donated 5 million dollars "to colored people" so he must be a good guy. Even though Mr. Dalton tried to help, he didn't accomplish anything. If he wanted to help, he could lower the renting rates of his apartments in the Black Belt, but even when Bigger tells him how much his family pays for a low-quality, one-room apartment, Mr. Dalton remains oblivious. He is removed from the situation and therefore cannot actually help, but he not only tries to act as though he is doing a good deed, he also does not admit to the fact that he exercises agency in Mary's murder case. He has the money and power to actually make a difference in the inequality between whites and blacks, but instead he presents himself as being superior to Bigger, especially when he emphasizes that he only needs to pay Bigger $20 per week but he is giving him an extra $5. Mr. Dalton's behavior perpetuates Bigger's hatred towards whites that leads him to be proud of the fact that he killed Mary. Mary also perpetuates this hatred by disrespecting Bigger and asking to see into his world. She is under the impression that she is helping Bigger by appearing to be his equal, but she does the opposite. She claims she wants to "see how [Bigger's] people live," but seeing is not the same as understanding and feeling. It is on the surface, just like Mary's desire to help blacks and whites be equal (69). She says blacks are human, too, but she refers to whites as "us" and blacks as "them" and therefore further separates the two races. Mary makes Bigger feel uncomfortable, and then angry for feeling uncomfortable, and the hatred grows even stronger. It became hard for me to sympathize with the Daltons as I began to understand where Bigger's hatred and emotions were coming from and I developed a sort of hatred for the Daltons, too. They're manipulative and selfish, but also ignorant, and ignorance is hard to cure. However, even when I try to forgive their ignorance, I cannot forgive their actions.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The whole notion that such a job could "turn Bigger's life around" is treated with skepticism by Wright. Of course, this *seems like* the far preferable choice to robbing Blum's. Bigger "does the right thing." And he's told by the housekeeper that the Dalton's helped the previous chauffeur to go to college. But Wright views racism in more structural-level terms, and takes a dim view toward the chances of any one person in Bigger's position "turning his life around" at all. The irony is that the "right" choice, the legit job, leads as surely to jail and death as the other option would have. In Wright's view, Bigger seems to be fully trapped by circumstance. And this, in a sense, the issue of sympathy is irrelevant. We can like him or not, affirm his choices or not, and these feelings simply don't matter--just as Dalton's personal feelings don't matter, or Jan's.
ReplyDeleteMr. Dalton and Mary are both very interesting characters to me, because they both very much exist today. I remember Mr. Dalton saying something along the lines of, "Should I live my life atoning for a problem I didn't cause?" referring to racial discrimination. This is definitely something I hear a lot when talking about things like white privilege. And while I don't think that he should live his life atoning for anything, he has actively profited form discrimination. Because blacks are forced to live in confined areas, he can get away with charging exorbitant amounts of rent -- it's either that or live homeless for most of them. If he really regrets this and cares about blacks as much as he claims, he should contribute in a meaningful way to the community. His charity efforts are simply attempts to give himself peace of mind. I think you put it best. It's possible to forgive Mr. Dalton for being unaware of the state of the black community; it's really hard to put yourself in someone else's shoes. But it's also really hard to forgive him for not even trying, and continuing to exploit African Americans.
ReplyDeleteI definitely agree that at multiple times the whites are putting down people like bigger even when they do not mean to. This is a very interesting problem because the Dalton is convinced that he is doing great things when he really is not. The challenge of getting a white man to fight for the good of the blacks has been adequately accomplished, but he, and many others, still have to change their attitudes. This next step involves thinking about how what they are doing makes others feel, not something they are used to doing with guys like bigger.
ReplyDelete