Thursday, September 4, 2014
Ignorance
Jim Trueblood's story is not a pleasant one, nor does it inspire much sympathy in me as a reader, but the white people who hear it feel the need to help him out. Rich white men, such as Mr. Norton, give him money for toys, clothes, food, etc., almost as if they are paying him off for raping his daughter. I think that the reason they are rewarding Trueblood is not because he committed a terrible act, but rather because he committed a terrible act that confirmed their expectations of him. The stereotype of a poor, black man is that he behaves in an unrespectable way, such as raping his daughter. The white men are content with this stereotypical man, as long as his actions are contained within the black community. The reason that chaos follows Mary's death in Native Son is because these stereotypical actions spilled over into white affairs. They didn't care about Bessie's murder, because that was a disaster that only affected black people. The narrator in Invisible Man is enraged when Trueblood tells his story to Mr. Norton because he knows that, just like all the other white men who have listened to the story, Norton will make a generalization about the black race as a whole based solely on Trueblood's actions. However, as we learned in philosophy class, an example cannot be a definition, so the white men who use Trueblood as a definition of black men don't actually know what they're talking about. The narrator is aware of this and shows the reader, but Norton and other white men remain ignorant, much to my dismay.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Like so much at this point in the novel, the question hinges around the narrator's "awareness." You're right that he is anxious about Trueblood's story because he believes that it will reflect poorly on "the race" in front of the powerful and influential Mr. Norton. If the narrator represents the trustee's "fate" as an upstanding college student, presumably Trueblood is the opposite (poor, uneducated, living in conditions that engender perverse relations, etc.), the embodiment of the thing the narrator wants to be "raised up from." But is he aware in the way you describe, where he gets what's *wrong* about Norton's presumed judgment? (An example isn't a definition--I like that formulation a lot, and it works in this case. But it's less clear to me that the narrator is thinking on this level. He mainly seems to intuit that he's about to get into big trouble with his boss.) In other words, if the false view here would be to associate Trueblood with all black people, the college seems to partake of the same logic, believing that their "good" students will "raise up the race" as a whole by extension.
ReplyDeleteI agree that the white communities we have encountered so far only seem to care about the black issues for exploitation and publicity reasons. In Native Son, Bigger's accidental murder of Mary makes headline news, while Bessie is disregarded. As a matter of fact, they also exploit her to back up their "black on white violence" argument, showing Bigger's strength and coldness. They don't really seem to care that she was maliciously murdered; they just use her as an extra prop. Relating back to Trueblood's story in Invisible Man, Mr. Norton seems intrigued not because it's horrendous and he's into that stuff, but because, as you said, this proves his preexisting stereotype of black people as a whole. It is unsettling to see him give Trueblood so much attention, but the relatively basic narrator not even a second glance.
ReplyDeleteI really like how you expressed why all these white men seem to be so rewarding of Trueblood--namely that he confirmed their negative expectations of him--and thus maybe the race. This is just one more shrap of negative “evidence.” However, in Mr. Norton’s case--while I think his fascination with Trueblood and his story does in part have to do with this confirmation, I feel like there is something more than that. How could Trueblood’s account leave him so unsettled, almost stir him into a frenzy of emotion? I keep coming back to one line right before the story is recounted:“‘You did and are unharmed!’ [Mr. Norton] shouted, his blue eyes blazing into the black face with something like envy and indignation.” Indignation makes sense in this situation, but envy does not. I think we all picked up on something weird when Mr. Norton was talking about his daughter in the car, and so although I don’t really feel like delving further right now, Mr. Norton’s ardour for his daughter and then this look of “envy” draws similar parallels to Trueblood’s story.
ReplyDeleteIt was ironic how Trueblood never received help from anyone when he was poor and respectable, but as soon as people find out what he did to his daughter, he is rewarded with money and new clothes, like you described. Perhaps the white folks of the town are giving him money not only to "reward" him for confirming their stereotypes, but also to keep him in town near the college, since before remember how the college was trying to convince him to move to a different town so they wouldn't be associated with him. Both white and black leaders of the town understood that Trueblood would be generalized to describe all black people if he remained in town, but after a very brief power struggle, the white people got their way like they always do.
ReplyDeleteI love the reference to philosophy and I agree that the Narrator might be afraid that Trueblood's actions will reflect badly on him, but I don't necessarily believe that Norton takes this example as his definition. Norton believes, or at least wants to believe, that these black students are his fate and will somehow make his daughter's death and/or his life more meaningful. As the vet so eloquently expressed, Norton doesn't even see the Narrator as a human being but merely a mark on a scorecard and this observation makes Norton extremely uncomfortable. Since this is after his exposure to Trueblood, I think it's safe to assume that his paternalistic attitude towards and view of black students (or black people in general) hasn't changed all that much. That being said, I completely agree with the earlier part of your post. The wealthy white men see Trueblood's actions as a re-affirmation of white supremacy, justifying any racist thoughts and actions.
ReplyDelete