During the discussion that occurred after we watched "Ethnic Notions" tonight, Coleman said that people are nostalgic for what they had or learned in their childhood, so even though they may be aware that a concept/practice is racist or bad in any other way, they still want to do/say/think it because it is familiar to them. That really resonated with me because I immediately thought of a series of Brazilian books that were made into a TV show that I loved when I was younger called "Sitio do Picapau Amarelo" ("Yellow Woodpecker Ranch"). The show focuses on the adventures of Pedrinho ("little Pedro"), Narizinho ("little nose"), and Emilia as they explore and enjoy life on the ranch. All of the kids, as well as their grandmother, Dona Benta, are white. Dona Benta has two black employees, Aunt Nastacia (who does the housekeeping and wears a head rag) and Uncle Barnabé (who is the groundskeeper and is constantly smoking his pipe), who look and act exactly like the Aunt Jemimah and Uncle Tom characters that are so familiar in stories from the U.S. There is also the resident troublemaker, Saci, who is portrayed as a coal black man with only one leg who hops around wreaking havoc and then disappearing with his magic red hat. Saci is a character from Brazilian folklore that is always black and always shown in an unintelligent, derogatory light.
The last time I thought about "Sitio" was probably when I was about 8 or 9 years old. I loved the show and I still know all of the words to the song in the title sequence, but now I feel ashamed that it is such a sentimental part of my past. I have to admit that when I started writing this post, I felt the desire to watch the show again, so I found an episode of it on YouTube. Even though I could now recognize how offensive and racist the show is, part of me wanted to just ignore the flaws because of the overwhelming nostalgia I was feeling. Although "Ethnic Notions," as well as our course, focuses mainly on racism and racial stereotypes in the U.S., I realized tonight that this same racism still applies in other countries. It is shocking and upsetting that the idea that "blacks are subhuman" is so widespread, but that also this message is conveyed often to children with young, impressionable minds. I definitely did not come to think of blacks belonging only in subservient or troublemaking roles from watching "Sitio," but, unfortunately, a part of me still wants to ignore the racist parts of the show and take a nice trip down memory lane.
This example nicely illustrates how insidious this stuff can be, when marketed to children. Because, unless you have the wider awareness of these stereotypes as a thing, you'd just see those caricatures as individual characters who are funny, clownish, in the way that cartoons are. We expect to see exaggerated laziness, stupidity, clumsiness, etc. in cartoons--and we laugh at and enjoy such depictions. No one claims that cartoons should exclusively provide solid role models--dumb can be funny. And if you don't know about the "uncle" and "mammy" stereotype and their historical context, it's possible to miss the racism entirely (just as no one claims that Elmer Fudd or Yosemite Sam are "racist" caricatures of white people--although people with speech impediments have a good case against Fudd, Porky Pig, et al.). But once you revisit the same characters with an awareness of their historical context, they appear in a whole new light. Among other things, it's an extremely lazy form of characterization on the creators' part--they aren't inventing a character but just tapping into a cruel and ugly preexisting template.
ReplyDeleteHey Isabel, nice post! I don't think you should feel ashamed even now because you were impressed on when you were a child. I can empathize with you, though, in that you have kept one opinion from the past, but are adding new ones that clash with it. And I think the point of this show -- or any show -- is to influence people and be interesting, so even if it's racist, you didn't have the tools to know how to focus on those flaws (as Mr. Mitchell sort of mentioned). This definitely made me think about how influenced children (not exclusively) can be, and that is it up to the people around us to educate us correctly (?!)... After watching Ethinic Notions, I definitely was thinking about the fact that some of the preexisting racism in our country (or even racism now) is due to the misinformation that those people have received. That's not to say that it's RIGHT, but just that there are more layers than just "horrible" to a racist comment.
ReplyDelete