Sunday, November 2, 2014

Show, Don't Tell

Every time that I have talked with Lisa about writing college essays, she stresses the importance of showing rather than telling, and I've been finding that, for me, at least, that is something easier said than done. I've been very impressed with Paul Beatty as I've read White Boy Shuffle because I think he is very good at showing his readers something and making them feel that they are really part of the scene. I felt that Gunnar's experiences at Mestizo Mulatto Mongrel Elementary at the beginning of chapter 2 was a really good example of this because I empathized with Gunnar as he dealt with annoying students, patronizing teachers, and confusing gaps that symbolize grade school. Obviously, Gunnar and I have a lot of differences, such as gender, race, socioeconomic backgrounds, etc., but his experiences at school were very relatable and easy to read. Most kids experience the embarrassment and disappointment of finding out that the claim they so confidently just made is, in fact, wrong. For me, I had this experience when I bragged to my second grade class about how well I could recite "The Lord's Prayer," only to have my arch-nemesis, Brianna, correct me when I accidentally skipped a line. I'm sure that no one else in my class that year remembers that incident, but it has stuck with me since then. Similarly, none of Gunnar's classmates probably remember when he was wrong about the Seiko XL-126's cultural origins, even though he evidently does. Gunnar's depiction of his experience in grade school is definitely tinged with racial inequality and injustice, but it also follows the framework of a typical elementary school encounter, which makes it more relatable, and thus more powerful. I'm excited to continue this novel and see, rather than hear, what else Gunnar's story holds.

3 comments:

  1. It makes sense to think of Gunnar as a relatable character, despite the numerous apparent differences he may have with any reader. People connect with his experiences, which Beatty allows to happen by drawing on the emotions in Gunnar's situations. I actually thought about this sort of writing quite a bit while reading Native Son, because Wright plays with the same feature of emotional connection in Bigger. Beatty and Wright are very different writers, but they share this trait of expressing the base emotions felt by their characters which turn out to be quite relatable. In the case of Bigger, readers don't necessarily have the same thought process (or experiences) as him, but I found it quite appealing that Wright exposed the raw emotion in Bigger that every human can identify with.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Out of all the books we have read so far, The White Boy Shuffle is the book that I have felt the most emotionally connected with. In part, that may be due to the fact that this is set in a time period closest to the one we live in, but I think it is also because of the main character's appeal. One minute, we're laughing at the way he's teasing his friends about the doctor's visit; the next, the wind's knocked out of you when he says things like "the summer of my molestation..." The author does a really good job of eliciting so many emotions from readers in such few pages, using the "show, don't tell" method.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I hadn't really thought about this to a great extent before-- but i totally agree with you. Even just the brief situations that are described while Gunnar is telling about his family tree are examples of showing and not telling. Beatty doesn't just say "everyone in the classroom was interested" but instead says that they ate their lunch while listening, etc. Although that's a small example, it really does make the reader more interested and able to relate. The scene where Gunner gets a physical, as awkward and non-relatable for a girl as it was, I still felt like I could connect with him. I'm glad you talked about this aspect of the book, because I think it's important even if it doesn't have anything to do with race or hard situations Gunner is in, but more with style and emotional connection.

    ReplyDelete