Disclaimer: I started this post before the film mentioned the similarities between Janie and Hurston...
While we were watching "Jump at the Sun," I was thinking about how I really need to write another blog post and that I wanted it to be about Their Eyes Were Watching God, but I wasn't feeling very inspired. However, then I started thinking about how Janie and Zora Neale-Hurston were kind of alike. From what we've heard, Hurston was a very confident and interesting woman who stood out from her peers. Many black women at that time might have thought of themselves as a queen, but they probably wouldn't have referred to themselves that way in public, like Hurston did. I don't think Janie would call herself "Queen Janie," but she also is unusually confident at times, such as when she speaks outs against the men on the porch of Eatonville who are supporting wife-abuse. Janie is also treated like a queen by other characters in the novel. Jody places her on a pedestal, but she is meant to be seen, not heard, and he doesn't give her much respect or power.
I also saw a similarity between Janie and Hurston in their tenacity to take care of themselves. Tea Cake didn't invite Janie to the party that he threw (even though it was with Janie's money!) because he wanted to protect her from the lower-class company that he was keeping. Likewise, he wants Janie to stay at home all day and tend the house when they move to the muck, rather than asking her to work in the fields with him. Tea Cake does both of these things in an attempt to help and look after Janie. However, Janie will not have any of it and insists on socializing with railroad workers and picking beans all day. Similarly, the film mentioned that when Hurston and her friend, Fannie Hurst, were traveling together, they often were not allowed to stay in the same hotels because of the different colors of their skin. When Hurst offered to stay in the same hotel as Hurston in solidarity, Hurston turned down her offer and claimed that she could take care of herself. This stubbornness and independence really reminded me of Janie at various points in Their Eyes Were Watching God.
"Jump at the Sun" said that Hurston didn't consider Their Eyes Were Watching God an autobiography, but perhaps Hurston's subconscious was in control while she was writing this novel because there are a lot of similarities between Hurston and Janie.
I'm glad you brought this up because as I was watching the documentary, I noticed the connection between Hurston and her Janie as well. I was surprised to find out that Zora actually grew up in an "Eatonville," an all-black community just like the one portrayed in Their Eyes were Watching God. She also mentioned that the center of town was Joe Clark's store, which is probably how she came up with Joe Starks. Her father was also the mayor of the town, and I found it interesting how she portrayed Janie's Eatonville man to hold that position too. I also think that Zora's orphaned childhood was reflected in Janie's lack of a traditional family. Finally, we learned about Hurston's three husbands and numerous affairs, and I think it's safe to say that this behavior is what inspired Janie's general independence as well as her own three husbands.
ReplyDeleteThe detail of her father being mayor of Eatonville intrigued me especially--when I think back to it, Joe and Janie's relationship does resemble a father-daughter relationship. He is very protective, wants her to be respectable, and is very concerned about her reputation and how it will reflect on him, because he sees himself as being responsible for her. I wonder if Hurston had a similar pressure on her, being the daughter of the mayor, and drew on that experience to write Janie's Eatonville episode.
DeleteThe novel might not be autobiographical in the strict sense of the word--Hurston never had to shoot a rabid, beloved husband, for example--but like most writers of fiction, she clearly draws on settings and situations from her own life in crafting her story. We see a similar kind of parallel between some of Ellison's experiences--leaving the black southern college in his junior year for New York, never to return--and the novel, it would be inaccurate to call _Invisible Man_ "autobiographical." Wright, too, had moved from the South to Chicago, and clearly drew on his experiences in the city, and specifically with the Communist party, in shaping his novel.
ReplyDeleteBut even more strict "autobiographical" writing isn't necessarily so clear-cut: the documentary discusses several "fictional" aspects of Hurston's "memoir," _Dust Tracks on a Road_. And we know she couldn't be trusted to give her age or birthdate accurately!
I had a similar occurrence when watching the documentary on "Invisible Man." I didn't realize that the book was supposed to be based off Ellison's early life.
ReplyDeleteIn terms of Hurston and Jaine's connection, I found the point that you brought up about their self-confidence interesting. This trait is apparent in much of Hurston's life: in her trips to the south, publication of questionable literature, and in dealing with her accusation of molestation. I think that this trait is less obvious in Jaine's life. Her insight on the porch seems more out of self defense rather than confidence. She only starts to exhibit confidence when she is not with a husband (before and after Tea Cake).