Today in class we talked about Sethe's memory of Sweet Home and its complexity. As I was thinking about it, I decided that Sethe's relationship with Sweet Home is unhealthy, maybe even abusive. I started thinking about Sweet Home almost as though it were a person, but considering how weird this novel is, I think it is okay to consider a plantation a person at times. But anyway, back to the topic at hand. Sweet Home has this emotional grasp on Sethe, as well as on Paul D., that is inexplicable and unfathomable from Denver's perspective. The plantation should signify hardship, pain, backbreaking work, enslavement, etc., and it does hold bad memories, as evidenced by Paul D.'s statement that, "it wasn't sweet and it sure wasn't home," but it also holds happy ones. Sethe and Halle were married and began to raise their family there, the Sweet Home men spent their breaks under trees laughing at one another, and the slaves certainly weren't scared of Mr. and Mrs. Garner. Mr. Garner treated them with more respect than most slaveowners, acknowledging that they were men, rather than boys, and, although she didn't allow a wedding ceremony, Mrs. Garner looked the other way as Sethe tried to make her marriage special and gave her a wedding present. Obviously being owned by another person is awful, but things got significantly worse once Mr. Garner died and schoolteacher entered the picture. His mistreatment of Sethe and the Sweet Home boys was a catalyst for their departure and all of the bad times that come up in Sethe's memory are associated with him.
It is understandable why Sethe and Halle left Sweet Home because they did not have a good life there, but it was also what they knew, clear and familiar, and 124 is the opposite. Life at 124 is suspended, with Sethe waiting for Halle to show up, and all of the unhappiness of Sweet Home came with them to freedom, but none of the "good" times are there. I think 124 was meant to be a stepping stone, but Sethe has never left it, never moved on, because of her ties to Sweet Home. Even though she knows it is a bad place and the life she left behind is not healthy for her, part of her longs for the time when they "were all together" and she knew what her life was meant to be. I feel sad for Sethe because she is obviously confused, but I hope that this abusive hold that Sweet Home has on Sethe does not come back to hurt her later in the novel.
Going out on a limb here, but can we compare Sethe's relationship to Sweet Home with Stockholm Syndrome? No doubt slavery stripped her identity from her, but at the same time it provided stability. She was held captive and the place was unhealthy by any terms, but looking back, it's the only place where she was part of a community. Now she's isolated and constantly dwelling on the past. Personal freedom or close relationships? It's sad and twisted that Sethe feels like there has to be a trade-off.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Michelle, Sethe's relationship to Sweet Home does have many of the characteristics of Stockholm Syndrome, but unlike most cases of Stockholm Syndrome, the effect has been instilled in Sethe since birth. She experiences strong emotional ties to Sweet Home, because (even though Paul D. points out that it's not sweet, and it's not a home) it is her home. It's the only home she can remember having, and even if it's a poor excuse for a home, it's still a home. A teenager wanting desperately to leave their hometown and go away to college will soon experience sentimentality and nostalgia for home (that's as poor a metaphor as Sweet Home is a poor home, but it sort of illustrates my point. Places will always hold strong associations, and the good are as strong as the bad.)
ReplyDeleteI would like to point out (and I apologize, because this is not related to your main point) that although Mr. Garner does claim to see his slaves as men and not boys, the dynamic between him and them that is arguably as troublesome as the alternative. We've seen a lot of instances this semester in the books we've read of this "respect" being a more subtle form of abuse. There's Jody, who severely limits Janie by placing her on a pedestal, and then there's all the white admiration for black artists in The White Boy Shuffle. I'd be interested in hearing more in Beloved about Mr. Garner, because if he is mentioned again, I think this dynamic will be spelled out more clearly.
ReplyDeleteWhat makes her attachment to Sweet Home even sadder is that the Sweet Home that she called home doesn't really exist anymore. When Mr. Garner was still alive, Sethe felt like she was almost a member of a family, but schoolteacher shatters this illusion for her and the other slaves and reminds her that Sweet Home was never her's. The Sweet Home Sethe knew and reminisces about is gone, and its alternative with schoolteacher is far worse than the isolation she experiences now.
ReplyDeleteWhile I agree that Mr. Garner has just as much of an abusive hold over his slaves as any other slave owner and it is difficult for Sethe and the Sweet Home men to see that sort of control for what it is, I do think there are valid reasons for Sethe's ambivalence to Sweet Home. I was thinking about Nikki Rosa, the poem which Athena discussed in class on Friday, and while this is in a different context, in a similar way, Sethe has memories of Sweet Home that aren't completely bad -- like Sixo and his potatoes -- resonating with the genuine constructive bond they had with each other at Sweet Home.
ReplyDelete