She didn't know to this day what their permanent teeth looked like; or how they held their heads when they walked. Did Patty lose her lisp? What color did Famous' skin finally take? Was that a cleft in Johnny's chin or just a dimple that would disappear soon's his jawbone changed? Four girls, and the last time she saw them there was no hair under their arms. Does Ardelia still love the burned bottom of bread? All seven were gone or dead. What would be the point of looking too hard at that youngest one? (163-164)
Slavery has broken, or at least severely damaged, Baby Suggs' ability to love her children and a mother's love is supposed to be unbreakable (although I don't know this for sure, seeing as how I am not a mother...). Reading about how Baby Suggs lost her children and the pain that it caused her made me appreciate her ability to move on with her life despite the hardships and help her remaining son and his family.
Sethe shows similar strength in her relationship with her kids. She devised a plan to help them escape Sweet Home and, despite the traumatic incident with schoolteacher and his nephews that she suffered right before she left, she did not allow it to hold her back from freedom and her children. She followed through with her plan and one of her children was able to be born into freedom. However, what really impressed me was the decision she made when schoolteacher showed up at 124. I realize that I just said I was impressed by Sethe's decision to kill her children, but I don't think it was good that she killed one and injured the rest of her kids. What impressed me was her intense love for her children that drove her to do what she did. Obviously killing her child took a huge toll on her because she loved them so much, but that was why she had to do it. She didn't want them to be taken back to slavery where they would have to live their entire lives in torture. It is a bit crazy, but she hurt them out of love and it took incredible strength to move on from that awful day and keep being a mother to Denver. She still hasn't healed completely, as evidenced by her conversation with Paul D before he leaves and the fact that she has remained at 124, unable to continue on with her life. Both Sethe and Baby Suggs have a lot of love for their children that has driven them crazy or made them cynical or caused something bad to happen, but the fact that they can live such tough lives and believe in love so much is part of why I really respect them.
I think you bring up a really good point. Without a doubt, Baby Suggs and Sethe are strong-willed and independent individuals. However, they are even stronger mothers. One could argue that they might border the limits of apathy rather than empathy, but I think I agree with you. All that Sethe and Baby Suggs did is out of love for their children and out of the strength of their character.
ReplyDeleteIn the earlier chapters when Paul D said that Sethe's immense amount of love for her children was dangerous, I was confused because having too much love doesn't seem like a bad thing at all. After reading your post, I can kind of see where he's coming from (though I still don't totally agree) because Baby Suggs and Sethe unconditional love did harm them in a way. I'm not sure if that is really related, but I definitely agree with you. What they did for their children really shows how strong they were as mothers and it's part of what makes them so strong as people.
ReplyDeleteI should have known asking myself a question like "would I kill my children for slavery" would be a dead end. The simple truth is that I have never experienced slavery, which on every account brutalized everyone involved, both the enslaved and the the slaveowners and even still, I don't know the answer. I don't know how appropriate this is, but I immediately thought about instances in the bible where people were willing to kill their kinsmen for God. I guess if you believe in something enough and love someone enough, salvation is more important than life itself?
ReplyDeleteI don't think that slavery has broken Baby Suggs' ability to love her children, but more so taken away what she loves. I think this is why Baby Suggs gives and loves so much in her new community; because she has no one left to give her love, as slavery has taken that away them her. Baby Suggs cooks for and takes care of her neighbors and even preaches about learning to love others as well as themselves. I don't think that slavery was able to take away her ability to love, as this remains unbreakable (in my opinion), but I do think that it made her accustomed to not loving any one thing too much.
ReplyDeleteI really like that you brought this up. Just in general thinking about the books weve read in this class, this book more than any other is one that does justice to women. It does not stereotype them, it does not strip them of their individuality, it does not marginalize them.
ReplyDeleteOne of the common themes I've seen throughout Beloved is that the very masculine characters are unable to understand SEthe's intense love for her children and write her off as crazy. Paul D is a little afraid of what lengths Sethe will go to to protect her children and from Schoolteacher's perspective of her act of love, she seems like a total lunatic.
ReplyDeleteOf course, Baby Suggs is both a mother and grandmother, and Sethe's "rough choice" takes the life of one of her grandchildren. And yet, unlike Paul D and Stamp Paid, she's not willing to condemn nor endorse Sethe's actions in the woodshed. There seems to be a kind of maternal empathy here, an understanding of what's driving Sethe even as she's horrified by it. Baby Suggs, though, is clear about who is to blame--not Sethe, in the end, but these whitepeople who "don't know when to stop."
ReplyDelete