We talked the other day in class about the similar dream-like quality in the battle royal scene and the scene in the hospital. In the battle royal scene, the narrator fights in a "big mirrored hall" that is "foggy with cigar smoke," (18). The battle is literally smoke and mirrors, but it is also an illusion that the fighting will benefit these black men, when in reality it is harmful to their health and dignities. The room has an overpowering smell of tobacco and whiskey, implying that the audience present are under the influence and therefore have fewer inhibitions. They are going to act differently than how they would in everyday reality. There are also a lot of examples of the narrator feeling that he has no power over his actions, a feeling commonly experienced in dreams. He says, "But as we tried to leave we were stopped and ordered to get into the ring. There was nothing to do but what we were told," (21). There is "sensual" clarinet music in the background, many shouting voices and noises that blend together, and people invading his personal space from all angles. Eventually he is thrust into darkness by a blindfold, saying on page 22, "Blindfolded, I could no longer control my motions." This further proves the lack of control similar to a dream. He can't even take full responsability for getting himself into the situation. He could have avoided the battle royal had he known better and he could have chosen not to pull the white valve, but again, he didn't know any better; he had very little control over his hospitalization. Once he is in the hospital, he experiences the surreality of a dream. He is awake and alert when the doctors discuss how to treat him, he tries to speak out to them, but they can't hear him. This is a typical scenario for a dream -- not being able to be heard by anybody -- and adds to the confusion and frustration of the chapter. Continuing with the smoke and mirrors idea, the scene in the hospital is an illusion of sorts. Hospitals are supposed to be places that help one get better, to fix what is broken. However, and this might just be my opinion, the "fixing" that the doctors want to do isn't helpful and shows the selfishness of these doctors. They want to try the lobotomy-like procedure, even though they are unsure of the reprecussions it may have on the narrator, and they yell, "Hush goddamit [...] shut up!" at him when he complains about pain and discomfort (232). The "fixing" that goes on in this scene only leaves the narrator frustrated and confused about his identity. The narrator is thrown into this operation without his permission and must go along with it. His situation reminded me of the naked lady dancing in the battle royal scene. She gets picked up by the powerful, drunk white men and thrown about. They disregard her needs and comfort and all the while, she is "fixed-smiling" because she can't speak out about her desires (20). The narrator's doctors are drunk on the desire to try something new for their own personal gain and he has no control over it either. I guess you could say that the narrator is a blonde prostitute.
I would never have thought to compare the two, but you draw some very valid parallels. The people around them are so swept away by their own selfish fascination and desire that the feelings of the Narrator and the prostitute are no longer a factor. They are both only seen as a means to an end, be that pleasure or a successful experiment. In these cases, they have been stripped of identity, humanity, and ability to protest.
ReplyDeleteYes--very interesting connection. I've definitely thought of the woman from chapter 1 as a fleeting glimpse of a kindred spirit for the narrator (there's no specific indication that she's a prostitute, although her role in this scene suggests she's a stripper or exotic dancer of some kind--no comment on the American flag tattoo!). She's there ostensibly to tease the young men in the ring, to confuse them further, to embarrass them and emasculate them in front of the leering audience. But the way she sort of crowd-surfs out of the room, with a twisted look of terror on her face, implies that she's being used, literally manipulated (moved about with hands) by the same men/social forces that manipulate the narrator.
ReplyDeleteUnfortunately, like so much else in this scene, she doesn't really register on his consciousness in any distinct way here, and the narrator will remain blind to gender issues well into his phase as a speaker on "the woman question" (which is coming up soon).