"De nigger woman is de mule uh de world so fur as Ah can see" (14) --Nanny
A couple of years ago, my grandpa (a.k.a. Norman, a.k.a. my biggest Facebook stalker) gave me a copy of Their Eyes Were Watching God for my birthday and I tried to read it. However, I was bored to tears before I made it through the second chapter. I was worried when I saw that it was on the syllabus for African-American Literature because I didn't think I could make it through on my second try. Therefore, it came as a surprise to me how much I've been enjoying this novel. I think part of why I like it is because the female protagonist provides nice diversity from our previous two novels. Zora Neale Hurston does a really impressive job of keeping her narrator gender-neutral, but the novel does fall short in some other areas. One of these shortcomings is the amount of stereotypes in the story. Unlike when the narrator is electrocuted inside of a glass box in Invisible Man or Bigger saws off Mary's head so he can stuff her body into the boiler more easily in Native Son, there has not been anything in the plot structure that has caught my eye and distinguished Their Eyes Were Watching God from countless other novels I've read in my free time. I was a little disappointed with Hurston when I noticed this, but then I started thinking that she also was in a different situation when it came to publish this novel than Richard Wright or Ralph Ellison were. While Wright and Ellison certainly had to deal with more hardships when it came to publishing a successful novel than most white men at that time had to deal with, Hurston had it even harder because she was a woman and black and therefore doubly oppressed. Although the women's rights movement had made significant progress in gender equality by the time this novel was published in 1937, women were still being oppressed and treated less fairly than men, so Hurston had to make sure that whatever she wrote would appeal to the public. In the opening scene, the narrator depicts one-sided characters, with all of the men being sexually attracted to Janie and all of the women bitching about her to hide their own insecurities. I was a little offended at how underdeveloped these characters were, but now I realize that Hurston had to make her characters relatable, and that's why they're called stereotypes, after all. Hurston didn't have much working in her favor when she wrote Their Eyes Were Watching God and, while her writing has some flaws, her background and circumstances make it a little more acceptable, or at least in my eyes.
It really sucks as to how hard it must have been for Hurston to publish her novel. Today in World Since, we saw a documentary about the the '50s, and it included a narration of how Grace Metalious, a white woman, published her novel, Peyton Place. The content of the novel is a bit on the radical side with all the sex and violence she includes, and this combined with the fact that she was a woman made it hard for her work to get published. The documentary showed how every publisher turned her down until she approached Julian Messner, Inc., which was the only publisher in New York run by a woman. This is the way that Metalious got her novel out and it emphasizes the point you made that Hurston had to make her novel relatable. Peyton Place resonated with the publisher of Julian Messner, Inc. and that is the only reason why it was ever released into the literary world. Its tough how unfair it must have been for Hurston, and maybe you are right in saying that she had to make the novel so one-sided without much freedom to do any different.
ReplyDeleteWhile you may be right, we can't assume that Hurston would have written a book on the magnitude of "Invisible Man" but didn't because of oppression. You can only judge what's there.
ReplyDeleteIn other words, it completely makes sense that Hurston might have written her book the way she did to get it published. But maybe "Their Eyes Were Watching God" is the best book that she could have written regardless of whether she was at a disadvantage (being black and a woman).
Personally, I find the simplicity of Their Eyes Were Watching God refreshing... it feels more realistic.
I do agree that the main concerns of the female characters in this book and the fact that the entire story revolves around Janie finding the right man seems a little bit out of place, and that one reasonable explanation for that is that Hurston didn't have a choice, she had to make the novel acceptable. However, this could have also been a deliberate choice, with Hurston using southern phonetic dialogue and one-dimensional characters with one-dimensional concerns to make a point about the independence of Janie to be able to break free from the life she was given.
ReplyDeleteIn some ways, it's hard for us to see what's so revolutionary about this novel because the kind of character Janie represents has become somewhat more common in Hurston's wake. There were very few novels focused on the experiences of African American women at this point, and pretty much none focused on women from Janie's marginal social status. Her very independence of mind--even if it does hinge on finding the right man to partner with, a reflection of the limitations of her time--was seen as revolutionary at the time, and continues to provoke strong reactions today. I've seen 21st century classrooms boil with indignation at her casual attitude toward marriage--and I suspect Hurston would find this rather amusing.
ReplyDelete