Saturday, October 4, 2014

Seeing Into a Woman's Mind

Yesterday Athena presented the lost baby poem by Lucile Clifton for her poetry recitation. Unfortunately, I am not someone who particularly enjoys poetry. However, this poem really struck a chord within me and has been in the back of my mind since then. For those of you who don't remember the poem or haven't read it, this is it:


the time I dropped your almost body down
down to meet the waters under the city
and run one with the sewage to the sea
what did i know about waters rushing back
what did i know about drowning
or being drowned

you would have been born into winter
in the year of the disconnected gas
and no car       we would have mad the thin
walk over genesee hill into the canada wind
to watch you slip like ice into strangers' hands
you would have fallen naked as snow into winter
if you were here i could tell you these
and some other things

if i am ever less than a mountain
for your definite brothers and sisters
let the rivers pour over my head
let the sea take me for a spiller
of seas      let black men call me stranger
always      for your never named sake

later i'll say
i spent my life
loving a great man

later
my life will accuse me
of various treasons

not black enough
too black
eyes closed when they should have been open
eyes open when they should have been closed

will accuse me for unborn babies
and dead trees

later
when i defend again and again
with this love
my life will keep silent
listening to
my body breaking


In class we decided that this poem was about a woman who had an abortion and is now apologizing to the child who she aborted. She is justifying her past actions and making a promise to her "lost baby" that she will make up for it with her future children. This poem has a sad tone, especially when she says, "black men call me stranger" in reference to her ostracism. I think one of the reasons that I was so drawn to this poem was because I felt a strong connection to the speaker that I have not experienced with other characters that we have encountered in poetry recitations or the novels we have read. I connected with her, in part, I think, because of our gender. We have met and learned about other female characters, such as Mary Dalton, Bessie, and Mary from Invisible Man, but we haven't seen things from their perspectives. I've been feeling recently that this is a very male-orientated class (I'm not trying to criticize the class in any way!) because our main characters have been male and during class discussion, the boys tend to talk more than the girls (aside from Katherine...) do. I think reading from the point of view of a female speaker was part of why this poem stuck out.
Another reason is because of the actual material of the poem. We have encountered female speakers in other poetry recitations, such as Coleman's and my choice to do a song by Nina Simone. However, this poem differs from Simone's songs because it softer and lacks the feeling of protest, whereas Mississippi, Goddamn and Four Women are both obviously trying to convey a message of what is wrong in the world. In this poem, the speaker feels guilt for aborting her baby, otherwise she wouldn't be trying to justify why she did it. I have identified and sympathized with Bigger and the Narrator, however I can't say that I've empathized as strongly with them as I did with the speaker of this poem. I am definitely not trying to start a discussion on abortion, however, I empathized with the speaker here because abortion is something that I, and I'm sure many other girls, have thought a lot about. While aborting a baby can be a choice made by a couple, it also has to be made sometimes by a single woman, like the mother in this poem. As facing this decision alone is something that I may run into one day, I felt a real connection with the speaker and I was truly sad for her.
Reading this poem was a much different experience than reading both Native Son and Invisible Man was for me, but it was good to stir up my feelings a bit, so good choice Athena!

6 comments:

  1. This is something I've thought a bit about as well. In both of the books we've read so far, I haven't found it too difficult to relate to and think about the protagonists -- in part because they are written in as protagonists and because the struggle and desire to make sense of the self in relation to the world is a universal ideal. However, the marginalization of women in both Native Son and Invisible Man does make me interested to hear the perspective of women. I remember being slightly (maybe a bit irrationally because I'm fully aware the novel is focused on Bigger) put off when reading Native Son because Bessie was so easily disposed of yet instrumental in Bigger's path to self discovery. Furthermore, Bessie never gets to achieve any freedom of the mind that Bigger does, drowning her sorrows in drink. At the same time, I can still understand and sympathize with Bigger and the narrator's perspective throughout the whole novel and Bigger's feelings about Bessie, Mary, his mother, etc/ the narrator's feelings towards women are so brutally honest and truthful that that in itself makes the novels that much more effective

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think Alice does an important thing in bringing up Bessie, and perhaps the differences between the narrator of this poem and Bessie are what allow you to feel so much deeper of a connection. While the overall tone is mournful, there is a hope and perseverance there. She feels incredibly sad and guilty about her baby, but it was lost--her circumstances in many ways forced this outcome. Instead of allowing this to desteoy her, she is moving on and promising to become a better person because of it. I think that at least partially, her strength is what allows you to relate to her. Perhaps that is too optimistic of an understanding of the poem, but oh well. According to Mr. Mitchell, we're too cynical and pessimistic of a class, so just working to combat that.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Part of what strikes me about this poem is the contrast between its speaker and most, if not all, of the female characters presented in the novels we have read. In "Native Son," both Bessie and Mary are one dimensional "filler" characters. The only purpose they serve is filling part of the plot. They don't get developed characters and we never get to experience their thoughts. The same applies to the women in "Invisible Man," none of them (Mary, Sybil, and Emma) are actually in the book for their character. They just fill spaces in the flow of the book. I liked experiencing the emotions of the lady in the poem; I hope we have more readings like that, too.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with what Katherine was saying about her circumstances forcing the outcome, but I also identified better with this poem than most because I can view her as a real person. She isn't one-dimensional like the female characters we've come across in "Native Son" and "Invisible Man." This made me think more about what we discussed in class today (or at least was mentioned in the movie), that Ellison creates his characters like a jazz musicians, with individually established identities. You don't see any of his female characters, black or white, as real people with feelings. I hadn't realized that the strong characters in both books were only men until you'd brought it up, but when both authors have been male you can't really expect them to understand what a black woman (double oppression!) thinks and feels. Poems like this are good to broaden our perspective on what all black people faced in this time period.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I can't believe I missed this post! Everything that has been said above influenced my decision to read this poem. I am actually really relieved that although it has been pointed out that the speaker feels guilty about her decision and that she owes it to her lost baby to treat her future children right, none of you said she *regrets* her decision. Because despite the decision having a certain degree of desperation involved, as the speaker reflects on the incident however many years later, she is determined to justify the means--it was her choice.

    ReplyDelete
  6. You mentioned that this poem doesn't have a protest-y feeling to it in the same way that "Four Women" or "Mississippi Goddamn" do, but I think do think that it does (although much more subtly) protest against the circumstances that force the woman to give away her baby: black men who "call [her] stranger" and don't take responsibility for their children, and a world that keeps her in poverty and then "accuses [her] for unborn babies" that she is unable to provide for. I also think it pretty openly protests against those who are vehemently anti-abortion, because it shows how in some circumstances, giving a baby away is an absolute necessity.

    ReplyDelete