Tuesday, September 30, 2014

Character Development

Disclaimer: I have not finished reading chapter 25 yet...
Today during class, I started reading chapter 25 of Invisible Man and I came across a quote that stuck out to me: "I felt no need to lead or leave them; was glad to follow" (Ellison 542). When I read it, I felt a sort of excitement for the narrator. He is at a crossroads in the scene when he thinks this -- he is able to either stay with the men, Dupre and Scofield, and keep looting the surrounding stores, or he can continue on with his original intentions of helping to calm the chaos that is going on in Harlem. I was proud of the narrator when he chose to "follow" Dupre and Scofield because it was his decision to do so. Up until this point, the narrator has struggled a lot with being forced to do things and having his freedom repressed. In the case of the Brotherhood, the narrator was forced into things from the start. He did not want to take the job with them, but the weight of his economic instability and Jack's persistence led him to call them back. Once he was in the Brotherhood, he was not given much say in what he did or what happened to him. If they wanted him at a party, he was told to go rather than asked if he wanted to or not. When giving a speech, the narrator was forced to stick within a set of guidelines predetermined by the Brotherhood, despite his natural inclination to draw from his emotional connection to the people. Before the Brotherhood, the narrator was constantly being ordered around at the paint factory by Brockway and Kimbro, and the only reason he ended up at the paint factory is because he was ordered to go to New York by Bledsoe. This scene was different from the rest of the book because the narrator was given the option of continuing down the path with the Brotherhood, one where he would be constantly ordered around while being under the illusion that he is a leader with power, or joining this new group of Harlem looters, where he would be fully aware that he was subjecting himself to being a follower. Neither option is good necessarily, but at least he is exercising agency with the second option. Basically, I felt proud of the narrator at this point because he is finally making decisions for himself. Sorry if this post is kind of incoherent, and if you disagree, I would love to here your opinions.

3 comments:

  1. The whole idea of exercising agency by following is such a rich paradox--one among many in this chaotic chapter. It seems wrong somehow to hail the narrator hitching up with a bunch of tenement-burning looters as a sign of progress, but this is precisely the kind of irony Ellison loves: just as the quintessential sign of "progress"--a college education--is, in this novel, anything but.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think that it is true here that the Narrator is exercizing his own agency--making a conscious choice to go with the looters. One way to look at the fact that he is still making a decision to follow is that this is a way for him to gradually transition--from completely following, to following who he consciously chooses, to eventually following himself.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with you in that the narrator eventually takes more control of himself. I think it's interesting because by the end of the novel, the narrator realizes that he has been invisible all along. I wonder if this realization is the reason he takes more control of his life, and I think you're right to be proud of him because it's hard to seize control over something that you haven't ever had control over before. Thanks for the post :)

    ReplyDelete